Ask Paula — Summer 2013

OK.Paula“Ask Paula” is your opportunity to seek advice and find answers about parenting and education.  Here, our gifted expert and CTD Director, Paula Olszewski-Kubilius, offers her insights.

Q: How can parents and educators ensure that they are not overwhelming or over-accelerating students?

Research has shown that acceleration, when used in schools, is typically done conservatively rather than “generously”, so over-accelerating is not usually a problem. However, the decision to accelerate a child is complex, involves many factors, and must be implemented carefully and thoughtfully. Above-grade level testing— e.g. 3rd through 6th graders taking the EXPLORE test (typically designed for 8th graders) and 7th through 9th graders taking the ACT or SAT (typically designed for 11th and 12th graders)– through CTD’s NUMATS program, is an excellent way to identify students whose reasoning abilities in math, science or reading are significantly above grade level and are, therefore, good candidates for subject or grade-level acceleration.

The key to successful acceleration is planning and managing expectations. Prior to acceleration, assessment of the child’s previous knowledge and skill level in the subjects he or she will be accelerated in is critical. For example, if a 6th grade child is being accelerated into algebra, a comprehensive test of pre-algebra and algebra can identify both gaps and areas of proficiency. It is important that both teachers, especially the receiving teacher, and parents, expect knowledge and skill gaps rather than perfect knowledge of the courses to be skipped, and work out a plan to address them. The plan might include some self-study over the summer or perhaps working with a teacher during the school year or using a flexible distance education program to fill in gaps (such as CTD’s Gifted Learning Links). If a student is being accelerated in language arts, the receiving teacher might suggest some specific literature or books for summer reading.

Another part of the plan for successful acceleration should be a timeline to evaluate the student’s adjustment and success in the new placement, using agreed upon criteria to measure these. Questions to ponder in devising a plan might include how long of an adjustment period to give; how often parents, students and educators should meet to assess progress and share perspectives on the placement; what the expected levels of academic performance, social integration with older students and independent study should be; and what is an alternative plan should the accelerated placement not work out.

Another component to successful acceleration is managing expectations of the teacher (e.g. that the student may not get everything correct and may have skill gaps, need time to adjust, be immature in some areas compared to the older students); of parents (e.g. it may be a rough start and the students may have an emotional reaction to an increased level of challenge and new social context); and of students(e.g. may feel under-prepared and lonely at first, may have to do some catch up initially). If full grade acceleration is being considered, one tool schools can use to determine if students are good candidates is the Iowa Acceleration Scale. It addresses many of the issues I have described, and helps educators and parents make informed decisions.

Not all gifted students are accelerated or choose acceleration as an option in school, but many do take on outside of school learning activities, extra-curricular activities, and additional courses to satisfy their interests and desire to learn. These are important activities for many children, giving them opportunities to connect with like-minded peers and receive instruction from enthusiastic and exceptional teachers. These activities engender motivation and build competencies and expertise. It is important to consider how much is “too much”, though. Growth in knowledge and learning, whether it is in a particular subject or in “non cognitive” areas such as organizational skills, result from the proper level of challenge and the right mix of challenge and support. Too much challenge creates anxiety and too little results in boredom and complacency.

What is “too much” is very individual and parents need to monitor and listen to their child for signs of distress, worry and anxiety that are excessive or do not dissipate over time. Parents and teachers also need to increase support for a student who has taken on a challenging course load or accelerates by actively listening to concerns and offering solutions, which might include adjustments to other aspects of a student’s schedule, assisting with communications with teachers and administrators, helping a student adjust expectations for achievement and friendships, and helping a student acquire study and organizational skills and effective coping strategies.

Time management is a critical skill to acquire and parents can guide children in thinking about what activities or courses matter most to them, require a greater investment of time and energy, or are critical to a future course of study. It is important that parents actively engage with their child in decision making regarding his or her choices for courses in school and outside of school programs and activities with the goal of helping them make the best choices and become independent critical thinkers and decision makers.

Do you have your own question for Paula? Let us know in the comments section below, or on Facebook, and watch this space next quarter for Paula’s replies!

2 responses

  1. Do you have any tips on what to do when a child or group of children needs acceleration, but the school refuses? They say they are differentiating skills within grade level, but 1) this is not really happening and 2) my child and several others had the material mastered before the school year even began. They wasted a year, and we’d like to avoid any more time wasted and bored, especially when these students are thirsty for knowledge! Thanks.

    • The following response is provided by Eric Calvert, NUMATS Outreach, Research, and Technology Coordinator at Center for Talent Development:

      Parents can help advocate for appropriate acceleration in several ways. The best way to start is to gather evidence of your child’s knowledge and skill levels. Keep a portfolio or scrapbook of his or her educational experiences and accomplishments. (This can be useful whether or not you are seeking acceleration. It is motivating for students to see evidence of their own growth over longer periods of time, and, as it accumulates, it can provide clues into students’ strengths, interests, and areas of exceptional potential.) Include things like school grade reports, test scores, news clips about academic and extracurricular participation, awards, and samples of student work. It’s not necessary to keep every spelling quiz or nightly math practice assignment, but larger and more open-ended projects and papers can reveal a lot about a child’s academic ability and development, and the comments and feedback teachers attach to these projects are sometimes viewed as being more objective than parental anecdotes by school administrators.

      Second, seek out assessment using an above-grade-level test. (Taking the EXPLORE, ACT, or SAT through CTD’s NUMATS program, which offers Saturday testing throughout the Midwest, is an affordable and convenient way to accomplish this.) Parents and schools will both want to feel confident that the child will be successful if advanced to a higher grade or course, so using an assessment that can compare a candidate for acceleration to other students already at the higher level can be more useful than grade-level measures.

      Third, find out what rights and responsibilities you have related to seeking acceleration for your child. Contact your local school board office and ask if there is a school board policy on acceleration or grade placement. Also, contact the gifted education consultant at your state department of education to find out about state policies that may be helpful. (Minnesota and Ohio, for example, have state legislation and guidelines for local policies on acceleration that many parents use to successfully advocate for their children.) If there is a district policy that your school isn’t following, contact your local school board representative. Finally, share copies of the Templeton National Report on Acceleration with your child’s teachers, principal, guidance counselor, school psychologist, and gifted education staff as well as the superintendent, curriculum director, and school board president. Many educators who aren’t familiar with the research on acceleration are resistant to considering the acceleration because they think they are protecting kids instead of stunting their growth. Their minds may be opened when shown the research evidence that proves that, for many gifted students, acceleration can be a great way to provide access to the more challenging curriculum they need with very little risk of negative social/emotional side-effects.

      Eric Calvert is the former assistant director for gifted education at the Ohio Department of Education, where he oversaw the revision of the state’s operating standards for K through 12 schools, administered university-based summer programs for gifted students, and oversaw the development of the state’s policy on academic acceleration, which has since become a national model.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s